Skip to article
창간37주년, 수원일보의 새로운 이름
News S
Search news
Weekly edition

아직 등록된 주간 지면이 없습니다. 발행된 지면이 등록되면 이곳에서 확인하실 수 있습니다.

신문 구독 문의

Jeong Ji-hwan's Yeouido Column A Society of Dead Referees

Jeong Ji-hwan, Senior Correspondent, Yeouido News

▲ Senior Correspondent Jeong Ji-hwan ⓒ Kim Jin-seok

A verdict (判決) literally means 'the end.' Especially when it is a wise judgment like 'Solomon's trial,' all the controversies, conflicts, and misunderstandings raised during the trial tend to disappear like lingering snow under spring sunshine, as if nothing had ever happened.

It is like imagining two ferocious beasts that were growling and roaring over prey peacefully going into hibernation. In such circumstances, carelessly objecting and expressing dissatisfaction invites the disdain of public sentiment before any legal sanctions.

However, the Constitutional Court's ruling of unconstitutionality regarding the Special Act on Building a New Administrative Capital appears to have become the fuse for even greater controversy. First, public sentiment in the Chungcheong region is unusually turbulent, and in this neighborhood famous for civility, a chilling new term—the "five traitors of Chungcheong"—is now a topic of discussion.

According to reports, the genealogy of these five traitors of Chungcheong, who have been targets of effigy burning at every protest rally, includes "the Constitutional Court, the Grand National Party, Lee Myung-bak, Seoul Mayor, the Chosun Ilbo, and the Dong-a Ilbo" (see Sisajenal, Issue 785, page 24), and it is said they have already been registered. This is akin to touching the whiskers of a sleeping tiger.

Constitutional scholars and civic groups have joined the ranks of those criticizing the Constitutional Court. Lim Ji-bong, professor of constitutional law at Konkuk University, criticized the Constitutional Court's unconstitutionality ruling through 'referee theory' (審判論) at a special lecture for Participation members on November 9.

He stated, "A referee exists to advance the game and help resolve disputes by applying rules that participants have established beforehand when disputes arise," adding that "the Constitutional Court's recent invocation of customary constitutional logic is equivalent to the referee arbitrarily creating game rules on the fly and exercising discretionary judgment over the actions of game participants" (see Citizens' Newspaper, Issue 571, page 2).

After the lecture, questions and opinions from ordinary citizens poured in. Among them, one citizen's blunt remark drew the audience's attention. He said, "All nine Constitutional Court justices are from Seoul, live in the Gangnam area, and officially possess assets of over 1 billion won, so it seems we live in completely different atmospheric layers," adding, "Not only did they invoke this strange theory of customary constitutionalism, but the fact that as many as eight out of nine supported the unconstitutionality decision makes me wonder if perhaps they were convinced it was a judgment based on conscience" (see Citizens' Newspaper, Issue 571, page 2).

There are two 'referees' in this world: 'law' (the judiciary) and 'speech' (the media). Due to their inherent nature, it was indeed the case that until a few years ago they enjoyed social respect and trust in abundance. In fact, in various surveys conducted in the past, they were classified as 'the most trusted group.'

However, through the tax investigation periods targeting press companies in 1999 and 2001, the referee called 'media' has already passed away. Watching the shameless conduct of certain faction-controlled newspapers that could not even distinguish between 'freedom of the press' and 'freedom of tax evasion,' the public's illusions about the media were shattered in an instant.

In fact, as evidenced by the military service exemption rate for faction-controlled newspaper owners exceeding ten times that of ordinary citizens, they are nothing more or less than the privileged class observed throughout our society (claiming rights while evading responsibility).

In the nationwide university student consciousness survey published in the Korea University Newspaper on October 10, journalists ranked third as 'the most distrusted group,' following politicians and business people. This serves as a 'litmus test' reflecting this changed social atmosphere. If one reads in the current state of the Constitutional Court a distorted portrait of the judiciary that has invited distrust as a referee, would that be a logical leap?

Send a news tip to Suwon IlboYour tip becomes the news · Your identity is protectedSend tip

Was this article helpful?

Comments —

Leave blank to appear as a reader.

All comments

Loading comments…