Skip to article
창간37주년, 수원일보의 새로운 이름
News S
Search news
Weekly edition

아직 등록된 주간 지면이 없습니다. 발행된 지면이 등록되면 이곳에서 확인하실 수 있습니다.

신문 구독 문의

Executive Branch and Judiciary Head-On Collision Over 'Judicial Composition'

Chief Justice of Supreme Court: "Difficult to Accept Claims of Procedural Defects"Cheong Wa Dae Immediately Counters: "Supreme Court Has Undermined Procedural Fairness"Supreme Court Justice Vacancy Exceeds 200 Days... "Separation of Powers Compromised"
President Lee Jae-myung and Chief Justice Jo Hee-dae (Newsis)
President Lee Jae-myung and Chief Justice Jo Hee-dae (Newsis)

The Blue House and the Supreme Court have collided head-on over the selection of Supreme Court justices.

According to political circles on the 23rd, the Blue House stated following an additional statement from Chief Justice Jo Hee-dae that "an attempt to exclude a legitimately recommended Supreme Court justice candidate from consideration undermines the fairness of the process."

The Blue House took issue with the fact that while the Supreme Court Justice Recommendation Committee recommended four candidates in accordance with the Court Organization Act, the Supreme Court individually contacted the candidates to confirm their intention to withdraw.

The conflict stemmed from the succession process for former Justice Noh Tae-ak.

The Supreme Court Justice Recommendation Committee recommended four candidates in January: Kim Min-gi and Park Soon-young, judges at the Seoul High Court; Yoon Sung-sik, vice chief judge at the Seoul High Court; and Son Bong-gi, vice chief judge at the Daegu District Court.

Chief Justice Jo submitted Judge Son as a Supreme Court justice candidate on the 18th of last month, but the Blue House requested resubmission on the 28th, citing "insufficient procedural completeness."

In response, Chief Justice Jo stated on the 22nd that "specific constitutional grounds and reasons to justify the request for resubmission cannot be found," effectively rejecting it.

The Blue House immediately countered that "the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court's authority to submit candidates is recognized as superior to the President's appointment power, which contradicts the Constitution," and that "the notion that the President must appoint whoever the Chief Justice submits nullifies the President's appointment power."

Chief Justice Jo issued an additional statement a day later and responded again.

He stated that "the official letter requesting resubmission dated the 28th of last month does not clearly specify the reasons for the resubmission request," adding that "under the wording of the official letter, clear grounds and reasons must be presented to proceed with procedures in accordance with the Constitution and laws."

Regarding the "procedural defects in the submission process" raised by the Blue House, he said it was "difficult to accept based on the provisions of the Constitution and laws."

Regarding the expression mentioned the previous day that "the President's acts under national law must be documented," he clarified that this did not mean there were formal defects in the Blue House's official letter itself.

Chief Justice Jo expressed that regarding the prolonged vacancy of the Supreme Court justice position, "I am sorry for the inconvenience to the public," and stated "I will do my best to ensure the process is completed promptly."

At the center of the dispute is Article 104, Paragraph 2 of the Constitution.

The Constitution stipulates that Supreme Court justices are "appointed by the President with the consent of the National Assembly, upon the submission by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court."

The Supreme Court maintains the position that there is no clear constitutional or legal basis for the President to request resubmission of a legitimately submitted candidate, while the Blue House contends that the President's appointment power is also an independent constitutional authority and that the Chief Justice's submission cannot effectively bind the President's judgment.

A personnel conflict surrounding a specific candidate has escalated into a clash over the President's appointment power and the Chief Justice's submission authority, and ultimately over the scope of the judiciary's composition authority.

The successor position to former Justice Noh has remained vacant for over 200 days.

A political figure stated, "The delay in constituting the Supreme Court itself makes it difficult for the normal operation of separation of powers," and "the longer the conflict is prolonged, the greater the political burden becomes."

Send a news tip to Suwon IlboYour tip becomes the news · Your identity is protectedSend tip

Was this article helpful?

Comments —

Leave blank to appear as a reader.

All comments

Loading comments…