Exclusive "Councillors Failed to Check Ordinance"...Suwon City Council Unable to Complete Organizational Setup for 4+ Months

Suwon City Council has failed to complete its organizational setup for over four months due to disagreements over the party-by-party distribution of committee members on the Ethics Special Committee, which handles members' ethical reviews and disciplinary measures.
According to Suwon City Council sources on the 16th, the council is pursuing a plan to process the composition of the Ethics Special Committee at the 2nd regular session of the 406th council meeting scheduled to convene on the 18th.
The point of contention is the party-by-party distribution of 10 committee members. The Democratic Party, the majority party in the city council, insists on composing the committee with 6 members from the Democratic Party and 4 from the People Power Party, while the People Power Party is demanding an equal 5-5 composition.
The Ethics Special Committee is a statutory committee established in accordance with the 「Local Autonomy Act」 and reviews matters concerning violations of ethical codes by members and disciplinary measures.
Article 2, Paragraph 1 of the 「Regulations on the Composition and Operation of the Suwon City Council Ethics Special Committee」 stipulates that the committee shall be composed of 10 members, including the chair and vice chair.
However, it was found that when the 13th National Assembly was launched, both ruling and opposition parties proceeded with committee composition without properly confirming even these provisions.
In the initial negotiations between the two parties in July, they mistakenly recognized the number of Ethics Special Committee members as '10 or fewer' and reached agreement on a 9-member composition with 5 members from the Democratic Party and 4 from the People Power Party.
However, when it was later confirmed that the actual regulations specified 10 members, a 5-5 roster was prepared by adding one member from the People Power Party.
The problem is that this provision had already been in effect for several years. The amended regulations that took effect on January 13, 2022 also specify 10 members for the Ethics Special Committee. The 12th National Assembly also operated the Ethics Special Committee with 10 members in October 2024. Among the current council members, there are numerous members serving their second or later terms.
Nevertheless, confusion surrounding member appointments arose from the first day of the new council's launch, as both members and the administrative process for composition failed to correct this beforehand.
According to actual meeting records, at the 1st meeting of the 402nd session on July 2, Council Speaker Kim Mi-kyung announced a roster of 10 members, but the meeting was recessed when members Lee Chel-seung and Lee Dae-seon raised objections.
After the recess, Speaker Kim stated that additional consultation between negotiating groups was necessary and postponed the agenda to the next day.
However, agreement was not reached at the 2nd meeting on July 3, and processing was again deferred to the next session. Since then, as of November, the Ethics Special Committee has not been constituted.
A local assembly, which represents citizens in enacting ordinances and rules and should monitor the compliance of executive agencies with laws and regulations, has failed to even properly confirm the basic provisions necessary for its own committee composition, causing delays in organizational setup, while the two parties continue to clash over personnel distribution.
Article 55 of the 「Suwon City Council Rules of Procedure」 requires the attendance of a majority of seated committee members and the approval of a majority of attending members for committee decisions.
Accordingly, if the Ethics Special Committee is composed of 6 Democratic Party members and 4 People Power Party members, if all 6 Democratic Party members approve, the committee decision can be made despite the opposition of People Power Party members. Even if all 4 People Power Party members are absent, the committee can hold meetings and make decisions with only the 6 Democratic Party members.
In contrast, in a 5-5 composition, if both parties' members attend and vote consistently with their parties, neither side can secure a majority unilaterally.
The 12th Suwon City Council, when the People Power Party was the majority party, operated the Ethics Special Committee in a 5-5 structure.
However, it is not uncommon for a majority party to fill more than half of the Ethics Special Committee.
The Gyeonggi Provincial Assembly composed its Ethics Special Committee with 13 members—11 from the Democratic Party and 2 from the People Power Party—on July 23. At the launch of the 12th provincial assembly, the Democratic Party's proportion of total seats was 86.2% (144 out of 167 seats), higher than its 84.6% proportion within the Ethics Special Committee.
Conversely, if the Ethics Special Committee in Suwon City Council is composed of 6 Democratic Party members, the party's proportion within the committee would be 60%, exceeding the party's overall seat proportion of 56.8% (21 out of 37 seats).
In the case of the National Assembly, the composition of the Ethics Special Committee has been delayed for an extended period due to issues of party-by-party member distribution.
The 22nd National Assembly has failed to compose an Ethics Special Committee for over 29 months since its launch. In July of last year, the Democratic Party and People Power Party agreed on a 12-member Ethics Special Committee composition plan with 6 members each at a National Assembly Operations Committee meeting, but it has not been processed at a plenary session.
Subsequently, in October, Democratic Party member Han Byeong-do and others introduced a new Ethics Special Committee composition resolution with 6 members each from ruling and opposition parties, but this time disagreements emerged over whether other opposition parties besides the People Power Party would participate.
Accordingly, Democratic Party member Noh Jong-myeon and others introduced a National Assembly Act amendment bill in June to make the Ethics Special Committee permanent and to appoint members by reflecting the party-by-party seat ratio.
The chief specialist of the National Assembly Operations Committee presented an opinion in the relevant amendment bill review report acknowledging the necessity of making the Ethics Special Committee permanent, while suggesting that careful review is needed regarding party-by-party proportional composition.
The report notes that if the seat ratio of multiple negotiating groups is directly reflected, members from that party could hold a majority in the Ethics Special Committee, raising concerns that this could compromise fairness in member disciplinary measures and qualifications reviews.
In particular, since the Ethics Special Committee is a body that reviews the disciplinary status of fellow members, unlike general standing committees, there is a need for discussion on committee composition methods that consider checks and balances between parties.
In fact, as of last month, 57 member disciplinary bills were submitted to the 22nd National Assembly, but no bills have been processed due to the Ethics Special Committee not being constituted.
A debate continues in both the National Assembly and local assemblies over whether to reflect proportional seat distribution of the majority party or to consider checks and balances between ruling and opposition parties.
Lee Dae-seon, the Democratic Party floor leader, explained, "The People Power Party is arguing for 5-5, and the Democratic Party is demanding 6-4, which has delayed negotiations. There are opinions that the Ethics Special Committee composition must be finalized at this regular session, so we are reviewing the possibility of proceeding with a 6-4 composition."
Choi Won-yong, the People Power Party floor leader, stated, "I understood it would be handled as 5-5, but if it has changed, we need to consult again and reach an agreement. If the Democratic Party unilaterally proceeds with 6-4 without agreement, there will inevitably be changes in the cooperative relationship between the two parties."
However, whether it will actually be processed appears to remain uncertain.
An official from the Suwon City Council secretariat stated, "The ordinance specifies 10 members, but we have not been able to determine the exact circumstances of why it was initially composed of 9 members. Information regarding the composition of the Ethics Special Committee roster has not yet been confirmed, and we have not been informed which plenary session will handle it."




Loading comments…