Choi Min-hee Says "Must Not Pressure Ethics Arbiter," But Jung Chul-rae Publicly Opposes Disciplinary Action

Democratic Party Supreme Council member Choi Min-hee said on the 17th regarding her disciplinary issue that "no one should pressure the ethics arbiter." However, a day later on the 18th, Jung Chul-rae, former party leader of the same pro-Jung faction, publicly came out "strongly opposing" the disciplinary action against Choi ahead of the ethics arbiter review. This represents public pressure in the opposite direction from those citing arbiter independence, prompting accusations of double standards both inside and outside the party.
Choi's remarks came in response to a statement issued on the 17th by 55 first-term lawmakers in the party, urging "swift and stern judgment by the ethics arbiter" and demanding severe disciplinary action and her resignation. While those calling for disciplinary action are being characterized as applying pressure to the arbiter, a public opposition to disciplinary action from the same faction's former party leader has followed.
On the 18th, Jung posted on Facebook: "I heard the explanation from Supreme Council member Choi. I believe her explanation that things were confusing and her intentions were distorted...I strongly oppose disciplinary action. It is not helpful to the party." This is the first time the former party leader has made a public statement since the ethics investigation into Choi began on the 12th, six days after the controversy erupted.
He also targeted Chairman Kim Min-seok regarding the timing of the recording acquisition. Jung wrote, "The confession that the 'Choi Min-hee recording' was already obtained last month is shocking...Was the timing controlled? That's speculation," raising suspicions about adjusting the investigation timing. He also stated, "Anti-division and anti-sectarian political pressure is political manipulation...Is there any larger corresponding conduct than this?"
Supreme Council member Choi faced controversy after it became known that she made remarks at a closed-door party member meeting last month suggesting that President Lee Jae-myung opposed the impeachment of former President Yoon Suk-yeol during his time as party leader. Chairman Kim ordered an ethics investigation on the same day the report came out on the 12th, and after receiving investigation results on the 15th, instructed referral to the ethics arbiter—effectively a disciplinary procedure.
The pro-Jung faction's "arbiter independence" logic has appeared before. Han Min-soo, a Supreme Council member classified in the same faction, appeared on a YouTube broadcast on the 16th, criticizing first-term lawmakers' statement calling for stern discipline, saying "When 20-30 first-term lawmakers and National Assembly members gather collectively and issue a statement saying 'punish severely,' that's trying to have an impact on the ethics arbiter...undermining the independence of the party's independent institution." If disciplinary demands undermine arbiter independence, critics argue that the former party leader's public opposition to disciplinary action, coming just a day after Supreme Council member Choi's "no pressure" statement, is equally subject to the same standard.
There are also observations about Jung Chul-rae having been a party member subject to ethics arbiter disciplinary action. In 2015, while serving as Supreme Council member of the New Politics Democratic Union (predecessor of the Democratic Party), he was referred to the ethics arbiter by party members for so-called "extortion remarks" directed at Supreme Council member Ju Seung-yong and received discipline, later regaining party office eligibility through amnesty.
On the 17th, Chairman Kim addressed suspicions about timing of the recordings, saying, "Some recordings from mid-October were not an issue, and this time the full scope has been confirmed, making the nature different and warranting different handling." He also emphasized stern and independent judgment regarding the referral decision at the Supreme Council meeting on the 16th.
As the pro-Lee party leadership and numerous first-term lawmakers are essentially requesting severe discipline, Jung's entry into the fray is expected to intensify factional conflict until the ethics arbiter makes its decision.



Loading comments…