Exclusive Administrative Restructuring Feasibility Analysis Report
Political circles are intensely debating administrative restructuring. Rep. Shim Jae-deok of the Uri Party recently submitted a resolution to the National Assembly urging administrative restructuring. This comprehensive reform of the current local government system is now being examined. This news organization has obtained exclusive Ministry of Government Administration internal documents analyzing the production effects and benefits that could result from administrative restructuring.
These documents were based on a 2000 commission by the Ministry of Government Administration to the Korean Institute of Public Administration, Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements, and Korea Economic Research Institute. Despite commissioning the study in 2000, the Ministry has not publicly released the results, fearing the impact of the findings. Currently, the Ministry is known to have established an internal task force on administrative restructuring and is proceeding with practical work.
With increased interest in local autonomy following the National Assembly's passage of the Special Administrative City Act, we examine the benefits analysis results of administrative restructuring based on Ministry internal documents.....<Editor's Note>
Administrative relocation generates 5-6 times larger total production effect
Analysis shows that administrative restructuring would generate production effects ranging from a maximum of 69 trillion won to a minimum of 31 trillion won. The resulting benefits would range from a maximum of 28 trillion won to a minimum of 12 trillion won.
These figures, compared to the Gyeonggi Development Research Institute's findings that administrative relocation would increase regional GDP by over 8 trillion won, confirm that administrative restructuring would contribute more to regional balanced development in economic terms than administrative relocation.
According to the Ministry of Government Administration internal data exclusively obtained by this publication, the cost of administrative restructuring is estimated between a maximum of 620 billion won and a minimum of 180 billion won.
According to the internal analysis document titled "Development Model of Self-Governing System between Provinces and Cities/Counties," five major types of restructuring alternatives are proposed: △city-county consolidation △special city and designated city introduction △province-city/county function separation △province function conversion △province-city/county function integration.
Metropolitan cities with 800,000-1,000,000 population show greatest production effect
The restructuring type with the greatest production effect is the province-city/county function integration model, which would consolidate provinces and cities/counties into approximately 50 metropolitan cities with populations of 800,000 to 1,000,000.
This model is similar to the restructuring alternatives currently being discussed in political circles. The Ministry of Government Administration analyzed that consolidating provinces and cities/counties into metropolitan cities would generate benefits of 28.76 trillion won.
The cost of restructuring is estimated at 625.4 billion won, with net benefits of 28.17 trillion won after deducting costs. Notably, if the administrative structure is restructured according to this model, employment generation effects alone would reach approximately 1.34 million people, with income generation effects estimated at 33.85 trillion won.
Divided among approximately 50 newly formed metropolitan cities, this represents an average income generation effect of 6.6 trillion won per local government.
Political circles are currently proposing that Gyeonggi Province be divided into 10 metropolitan cities through province-city/county consolidation designated as metropolitan cities.
Under this proposal, Gyeonggi Province would be divided into 10 cities: △Suwon, Hwaseong, Osan △Yongin, Icheon, Yeoju △Pyeongtaek, Anseong △Anyang, Gunpo, Uiwang, Gwacheon △Siheung, Gwangmyeong, Ansan △Bucheon, Gimpo △Goyang, Paju △Uijeongbu, Pocheon, Yeoncheon, Dongducheon, Yangju △Guri, Namyangju, Gapyeong, Yangpyeong △Seongnam, Hanam, Gwangju. These would form 10 zones.
Applying this model, arithmetic calculations show that each newly restructured local government would generate over 6 trillion won in income.
Suwon expected to generate over 6 times its annual budget in income effects
Specifically, if Suwon consolidates with Hwaseong and Osan and is restructured into a metropolitan city based on population ratio, it would generate income effects of 6.6 trillion won. This figure is six times Suwon's total 2005 revenue and expenditure budget of 1.18 trillion won.
If administrative restructuring is implemented through special city or designated city status, income generation effects are expected to reach approximately 3 trillion won to 2.3 trillion won.
According to Ministry internal documents, if the special city and designated city introduction model is adopted, benefits would reach 12.60 trillion won, with 31.95 trillion won in production effects nationally. Additionally, 609,000 people would gain new employment, and 15.32 trillion won in new income would be created.
This model, which grants metropolitan city functions to special cities and designated city status to cities with current populations exceeding 500,000, would cost 189.6 billion won—not significantly different from the cost of simple consolidation of uncompetitive cities and counties (189.5 billion won).
According to the data, if province-city/county functions are separated and special local government agency duties are transferred to provinces, 14.46 trillion won in benefits would be generated. Restructuring costs would be 189.6 billion won, with income generation effects estimated at 16.36 trillion won and employment benefits exceeding 6.45 million people.
These figures demonstrate that function separation between provinces and cities/counties alone could enable some local governments currently experiencing severe fiscal dependency to secure substantial financial resources.
Province-city/county function separation alone generates 14 trillion won in benefits
Notably, if provincial self-governing functions are eliminated, provinces are transformed into national administrative agencies, and 234 cities/counties/districts are consolidated into approximately 100 competitive cities and counties, benefits would reach 26.13 trillion won. Income generation effects alone would exceed 32 trillion won, benefiting over 12.87 million new workers with employment opportunities.
This Ministry analysis quantifies the costs and benefits of actual administrative restructuring based on current political proposals. If restructuring discussions continue, this data is likely to serve as valuable information for estimating actual budget requirements and resulting economic effects.
However, the survey's 2000 timeframe is noted as a weakness. Since the survey targeted 158 cities and counties at that time (current total is 234 city/county/districts), there could be some variance in specific figures.
<Yeouido Communications=Reporter Kim Dong-hyun>
Loading comments…