Friction erupted between Suwon City Council members and high-ranking municipal officials over the operating budget for Suwon's food waste disposal facility, with pointed fingers and raised voices exchanged.
The Budget and Settlement Special Committee Subcommittee No. 2 of the Suwon City Council held a review on the 2nd of supplementary budget proposals under the jurisdiction of the Finance and Economy Committee, and cut 350 million won from the 911.5 million won in operating budget for the food waste disposal facility requested by the city.
Prior to this, the Finance and Economy Committee, which had reviewed the budget, cut 500 million won citing excessive budget allocation for facility operations and insufficient countermeasures from the city regarding food waste incineration facilities, and passed 411.5 million won to the Special Committee.
During the review that day, the Subcommittee No. 2 of the Special Committee stated that the relevant city department was claiming "the food waste treatment cost has been cut too much, and there is no plan for handling food waste that will occur later," and argued "a minimum budget of 611 million won must be allocated to handle all garbage in the city, otherwise a garbage crisis will occur," requesting reconsideration. They then called in Councilmember Cha Geung-ho (Pyeongdong), who was on the Finance and Economy Committee, to discuss the rebudgeting.
However, Councilmember Cha stated, "Currently, the Pyeongdong food waste incinerator, which has a daily capacity of 100 tons, is burning 30 to 40 tons more than that," and added, "Because of this, nearby residents are suffering from odor and other problems, but the city has taken no measures and instead only requests excessive treatment costs." He continued, "If we approve the city's request, overcapacity at the incinerator will continue, and only nearby residents will suffer," opposing the budget increase.
Councilmember Cha said, "When requesting a budget, the city should not simply demand treatment costs alone, but should present countermeasures such as developing city-wide campaigns and events to reduce food waste," and stated, "There is absolutely no such effort, and they're only asking for money to dump food waste. I absolutely cannot accept this."
Faced with Councilmember Cha's strong stance, Subcommittee No. 2 backed down, instructing city department employees to "request the budget derived through agreement with Councilmember Cha." The employees then asked Councilmember Cha to "rebudget at least the minimum treatment cost of 600 million won or so," noting that "food waste increases during the four-month period from June to September."
Councilmember Cha responded, "I'm not sure what basis the 600 million won budget was calculated from, but according to the data I have, if we calculate an average monthly treatment cost of about 120 million won each, 500 million won would be sufficient for the four-month budget. If the city submits a budget for the second half, I will allocate the remaining budget at that time."
The relevant employees continued to request at least 600 million won in treatment costs, and as the review was delayed, Park Director of the Environment and Green Space Bureau Kwon In-taek visited the review room around 3:20 p.m. that day, requesting budget reallocation.
'Budget Review Meeting Descends into Bedlam'
As back-and-forth negotiations occurred between the city councilmember and city staff over food waste treatment costs, the budget review room instantly descended into chaos.
When Director Kwon, who visited the review room around 3:20 p.m. that day, asked, "If the budget is not set, how will the food waste generated throughout the city be treated?" and argued, "If we don't even provide the minimum budget, a garbage crisis will occur," requesting reconsideration from the Special Committee members and Councilmember Cha.
However, Councilmember Cha countered, "Isn't the city's attitude irresponsible?" and argued, "The incinerator itself is in an oversaturated state, causing nearby residents to suffer, yet the city's countermeasures are at zero level. Stop thinking about dumping garbage unconditionally and come up with measures to reduce waste."
Infuriated by the phrase "countermeasures at zero level," Director Kwon immediately responded, "In my 30 years as a civil servant, I've never been disrespected like this. Don't talk as if we're not doing our jobs."
With his face reddened, Director Kwon stood up abruptly and protested, "Aren't you going too far now that you have authority? You're always talking about cutting public servants' heads off. How can this continue?"
Councilmember Cha shot back, "Why are you making things up? I never said anything about cutting heads off. If you're not doing the work, why should we keep approving the budget?"
As the two suddenly stood up and began pointing fingers at each other while speaking informally, moving toward a physical confrontation, surrounding councilmembers restrained both of them.
Unable to contain his anger, Director Kwon left the review room but returned about three minutes later to apologize to the Special Committee members, saying, "I'm sorry. I got too excited." As Councilmember Cha said, "Don't make things up. You and your staff are unaware of residents' suffering and act this way," another confrontation erupted.
Director Kwon responded, "Who do you think you're talking to with 'you'? If you act this way, I won't let it slide," and Councilmember Cha protested, "What are you going to do if you don't let it slide?" before they clashed again.
The Budget and Settlement Committee specialist member and city councilmembers nearby took Director Kwon out of the review room, and the bedlam that had lasted over ten minutes came to an end.
Food Waste Treatment Budget Outcome Draws Attention
Unable to narrow differences, Subcommittee No. 2 of the Special Committee ultimately set the food waste treatment budget at 561.5 million won, the midpoint between Councilmember Cha's position and the city's request, cutting 350 million won from the original budget plan and passed it.
The budget plan will be submitted to the city council's second regular session on the 4th if it passes the final review of the Special Committee on the 3rd, where the final decision will be made.
Currently, the Pyeongdong food waste incinerator was built to accommodate an average of 100 tons of food waste daily, but last year an average of 147 tons of food waste was brought in daily, creating an overcapacity situation.
Meanwhile, the city's initially requested minimum treatment cost of 611.5 million won was based on the explanation that food waste increases by 20 to 30 percent compared to the monthly average during the summer months from June to September last year. However, looking at last year's compost facility operating cost expenditure, the costs spent during this period did not increase significantly compared to last year's average.
In February and November last year, 4,227 tons and 4,447 tons of food waste were brought in, respectively, while in July and August last year, 5,206 tons and 4,607 tons, respectively—more than other periods—were brought in.
However, treatment costs in February and November last year were approximately 80.7 million won and 128.9 million won, respectively, while in July and August last year, approximately 114.1 million won and 118.9 million won were spent, respectively, showing no significant difference in expenditure and actually less than last year's monthly average treatment cost of approximately 106.76 million won.
Also, the treatment costs from June to September last year totaled approximately 455.7 million won, which was more than the 411.5 million won that passed the Finance and Economy Committee and less by 55.8 million won than the 511.5 million won that Councilmember Cha presented.
Accordingly, the 561.5 million won that passed Subcommittee No. 2 of the Special Committee that day, when compared to last year's expenditure figures, even accounting for salary increases, becomes an amount sufficient to use until the second supplementary budget review scheduled for September to October.
In an interview with this publication after the Special Committee review ended that day, Councilmember Cha said, "The greatest influence local councilmembers can exert on the executive branch is through budget review," and explained, "The significant initial budget cuts were intended to check the city's executive branch's complacent attitude of not prioritizing countermeasures while disregarding residents' suffering, and to ensure participation in every budget review session."
Loading comments…