Teacher Evaluation Application Status Criticized for Lack of Transparency
The Gyeonggi Province Office of Education is facing criticism for lacking conviction in its administration, as it has refused to disclose not only the names of schools participating in the pilot program for teacher evaluation but also the number of schools, citing concerns about resistance from the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (KTU).
A Gyeonggi Province Office of Education official stated on the morning of the 17th, "We submitted the list of pilot program applicant schools to the Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development today."
However, the official said, "We cannot disclose the names of schools that have submitted applications or even how many schools have applied," adding that "an order for confidentiality regarding application submission status was issued by senior management."
The Gyeonggi Province Office of Education reportedly issued the confidentiality order out of concern that teachers affiliated with the KTU would visit the provincial education office and applicant schools to lodge protests if the number and names of schools were disclosed.
This measure by the provincial education office drew criticism as "administration lacking conviction" when compared to other provincial and metropolitan education offices that disclosed their application reception status on the same morning.
According to sources around the provincial education office, three schools submitted applications by the application deadline at noon on the 16th, but one school withdrew its application, and four to five other schools subsequently submitted additional applications, bringing the total number of schools in the province expressing intent to participate in the teacher evaluation pilot program to approximately six to seven.
The Ministry of Education selected three schools in the province on the afternoon of the same day—one elementary school, one middle school, and one high school—as teacher evaluation pilot schools.
An official from the Gyeonggi branch of the KTU said, "Just as the Ministry of Education and the provincial education office are concerned, teachers affiliated with the KTU will not visit schools that submitted teacher evaluation participation applications to lodge group protests." The official added, "Watching the provincial education office refuse to even disclose the number of applicant schools out of concern about KTU resistance makes me wonder why they are undertaking such a task if they lack such confidence."
The official stated, "Our position opposing the government's unilateral implementation of the teacher evaluation pilot program remains unchanged," and added, "We will monitor the Ministry of Education's actions and respond actively to teacher evaluation in accordance with directives from our headquarters."
The Ministry of Education announced that following recruitment from 16 provincial and metropolitan education offices nationwide, 116 schools applied—including 62 elementary schools, 26 middle schools, and 28 high schools. On the 17th, 48 elementary, middle, and high schools were selected to pilot the teacher evaluation system by August of next year.
Loading comments…