Metropolitan Cities Should Be Abolished and Integrated into Provinces
An argument has been raised that metropolitan cities should be abolished and integrated into provinces, as the current four-tiered urban administrative system—consisting of metropolitan cities and other categories—is only promoting the expansion of city sizes.
Professor Kim Ik-sik of Kyonggi University (Department of Public Administration) argued in a paper presented at the 2006 Autumn Academic Conference hosted by the Gyeonggi Development Institute on the 1st that "the current urban administrative structure induces the expansion of city scales according to the urbanization incentive effect," and that "as a result, problems such as intensification of urban issues, decreased accessibility of urban governments, and diminished civic participation can occur."
South Korea's current urban administrative system consists of a four-tiered structure: general cities with populations of 50,000 or more, large metropolitan cities with 500,000 or more residents (12 cities), metropolitan cities with 1 million or more (6 cities), and special cities (1 city).
Professor Kim stated that "the elevation of metropolitan cities has caused regional hollowing due to the loss of centerpoints in provinces, and has weakened remaining provincial competitiveness in finance, population, and other aspects including provincial tax revenue," adding that "the current metropolitan city system has far more disadvantages than advantages and requires fundamental review."
Meanwhile, Professor Kim argued that as metropolitan cities expand, large cities with populations of 500,000 or more face discrimination, with their administrative personnel and organizational scales being inadequate compared to administrative demands.
In fact, the ratio of residents per government official in the 12 large metropolitan cities with 500,000 or more residents stands at 374 people, 50% higher than the national average of 248 people.
In particular, in Gyeonggi Province, which has seven of the 12 large metropolitan cities including Suwon (1.04 million), Seongnam (980,000), and Goyang (900,000), the ratio of residents per government official reached 442 people, double the national average.
Accordingly, Professor Kim suggested that "the metropolitan city system should be completely abolished and converted back to provincial jurisdiction," proposing to comprehensively consider abolished metropolitan cities and large cities with populations of 500,000 or more, and to divide them into first-class metropolitan cities (1 to 3 million) and second-class metropolitan cities (500,000 to 1 million), offering differentiated special privileges as metropolitan cities.
Professor Kim stated that "the basic direction for improving the administrative system should be to avoid the hierarchical classification of cities as much as possible," and that "to expand special privileges for large cities with 500,000 or more residents, abolishing the metropolitan city system entirely or partially must be a prerequisite condition."


Loading comments…